Peer review proces
Peer Review Process
Multidisciplinary Journal Enfoque Transversal
The Multidisciplinary Journal Enfoque Transversal, published by Editorial Ciencia Global, follows a peer review process designed to ensure the academic quality, originality, relevance, and scientific integrity of the manuscripts submitted for publication.
The evaluation process is conducted according to principles of impartiality, confidentiality, transparency, academic independence, and respect for ethical standards in scholarly publishing.
General Peer Review Policy
All manuscripts submitted to the journal are subject to an editorial screening process and, when considered suitable, an external peer review process. The purpose of this procedure is to assess the scientific quality, originality, methodological rigor, relevance, and contribution of each manuscript to its respective field of knowledge.
Submission of a manuscript does not guarantee its acceptance or publication. Editorial decisions are based on the manuscript's academic merit, the reviewers' recommendations, the journal's editorial policies, and compliance with publication ethics.
Submission and Initial Verification
Upon receipt, the editorial team verifies that the manuscript meets the journal's basic submission requirements. This initial review may include checking the following aspects:
- Compliance with the journal's author guidelines.
- Appropriate manuscript structure and presentation.
- Relevance to the journal's scope and areas of interest.
- Completeness of the required documents and declarations.
- Compliance with applicable ethical requirements.
- Preliminary checks for originality and possible plagiarism.
Manuscripts that do not meet the basic requirements may be returned to the authors for correction or rejected before external review.
Preliminary Editorial Review
The editorial team conducts a preliminary assessment to determine whether the manuscript is suitable for the journal's scope and whether it meets the minimum standards required to proceed to peer review.
At this stage, the editorial team may reject manuscripts that lack sufficient originality, do not present an adequate academic contribution, show significant methodological weaknesses, or fall outside the journal's scope.
Selection of External Reviewers
Manuscripts that pass the preliminary editorial review may be sent to external reviewers with relevant academic and professional expertise in the subject area of the submission.
Reviewers are selected based on their subject knowledge, research experience, and ability to provide an objective and constructive assessment. The journal seeks to avoid conflicts of interest that could compromise the independence or impartiality of the evaluation.
Double-Blind Peer Review
The journal applies a double-blind peer review model, provided that the submitted manuscript and review process meet the necessary conditions for maintaining anonymity. Under this model, the identities of the authors are not disclosed to the reviewers, and the identities of the reviewers are not disclosed to the authors.
Authors are responsible for removing identifying information from the manuscript and its supplementary files when required. Reviewers must respect the confidentiality of the process and must not attempt to identify the authors.
Evaluation Criteria
Reviewers assess manuscripts according to criteria appropriate to their nature, subject area, and research methodology. These criteria may include:
- Originality and relevance of the topic.
- Scientific or academic contribution.
- Clarity of objectives and research questions.
- Consistency and rigor of the methodology.
- Accuracy and interpretation of results.
- Quality of the discussion and conclusions.
- Appropriate use of references and supporting sources.
- Clarity, organization, and academic writing quality.
- Compliance with ethical standards applicable to the research.
Review Reports
Reviewers provide an assessment of the manuscript, identifying its strengths, weaknesses, and areas requiring improvement. Their reports should be objective, evidence-based, respectful, and sufficiently detailed to help the authors improve their work.
Reviewers may recommend acceptance, acceptance subject to minor revisions, resubmission after major revisions, or rejection. These recommendations are advisory and do not replace the final decision of the editor responsible for the manuscript.
Editorial Decisions
Based on the review reports, the preliminary assessment, and the journal's editorial policies, the editor may make one of the following decisions:
- Accept: The manuscript is accepted for publication, subject to any applicable editorial and production requirements.
- Minor revisions: The authors must address specific observations before the manuscript can be accepted.
- Major revisions: Substantial changes are required, and the revised manuscript may be returned for further evaluation.
- Reject: The manuscript does not meet the standards or requirements for publication in the journal.
The editorial decision and the relevant reviewer comments are communicated to the authors through the journal's editorial platform or another official communication channel.
Revision of Manuscripts
When revisions are requested, authors must submit a revised version within the period specified by the editorial team. They should also provide a response document explaining how each reviewer comment has been addressed or providing a reasoned justification when a suggestion has not been adopted.
Revised manuscripts may be reviewed by the editor and, when necessary, returned to the original reviewers or sent to new reviewers. Submission of a revised version does not automatically guarantee acceptance.
Review Timelines
The time required to evaluate a manuscript may vary depending on the availability of qualified reviewers, the complexity of the subject, the number of revisions required, and the timely responses of the authors and reviewers.
The editorial team endeavors to manage the process efficiently and communicate relevant updates to authors. Any indicative review timelines published by the journal should be understood as estimates rather than guaranteed deadlines.
Confidentiality of the Review Process
Manuscripts under review are treated as confidential documents. Reviewers and editorial team members must not disclose, distribute, or use unpublished information obtained through the evaluation process for personal, academic, or professional benefit.
Review reports, editorial communications, and the identities of reviewers are handled confidentially, subject to applicable legal obligations and the journal's established policies.
Independence of Editorial Decisions
Editorial decisions are based on academic quality, the relevance of the manuscript, the reviewers' assessments, and compliance with the journal's editorial and ethical standards. Decisions must not be influenced by the authors' nationality, institutional affiliation, personal characteristics, or financial considerations unrelated to the journal's stated policies.
Editors and reviewers must disclose any potential conflict of interest and withdraw from the process when their impartiality could reasonably be questioned.
Final Provision
The Multidisciplinary Journal Enfoque Transversal reserves the right to update its peer review procedures when necessary to improve the quality, transparency, and integrity of its editorial process. Any changes will be published through the journal's official channels.
Institutional Information
Journal: Multidisciplinary Journal Enfoque Transversal
Publisher: Editorial Ciencia Global
Country: Ecuador
Editorial platform: Open Journal Systems (OJS)
Official website: Visit the journal website
Commitment to Academic Quality and Integrity
Editorial independence, rigorous evaluation, confidentiality, and ethical responsibility are fundamental principles of the journal's peer review process.
```