Policy on scientific misconduct
Policy on Scientific Misconduct
Multidisciplinary Journal Enfoque Transversal
The Multidisciplinary Journal Enfoque Transversal, published by Editorial Ciencia Global, is committed to scientific integrity, editorial transparency, and the responsible dissemination of knowledge. Accordingly, it establishes this policy to prevent, identify, and address potential scientific misconduct throughout the submission, peer review, editing, and publication processes.
This policy is based on the principles of honesty, accountability, impartiality, confidentiality, and respect for the ethical standards applicable to research and scholarly publishing. In its implementation, the journal draws on the guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), taking into account the nature of each individual case.
Conduct Considered Scientific Misconduct
Scientific misconduct includes actions that compromise the authenticity, reliability, originality, or ethical integrity of research and scholarly publications. Such conduct may include, but is not limited to, the following:
- Plagiarism: Appropriating or presenting ideas, texts, data, images, results, or contributions from third parties without appropriate acknowledgment.
- Self-plagiarism and redundant publication: Substantially reusing one's own previously published work without transparency, or publishing overlapping results in multiple sources without adequate justification or disclosure.
- Data fabrication: Inventing data, observations, results, or evidence that were not actually obtained.
- Data falsification: Deliberately manipulating, altering, or omitting data, procedures, images, or results in a way that misrepresents the research.
- Improper image manipulation: Misleadingly modifying images, figures, or graphs in a manner that alters their scientific interpretation.
- Improper authorship: Unjustifiably including or excluding individuals, attributing contributions that were not made, or listing someone as an author without their consent.
- Undisclosed conflicts of interest: Failing to disclose relevant personal, professional, institutional, or financial interests.
- Ethical violations in research: Failing to obtain required authorizations or informed consent, or neglecting appropriate safeguards when research involves human participants, animals, or other protected subjects or materials.
- Manipulation of the editorial process: Impersonating reviewers, falsifying review reports, improperly interfering with peer review, or submitting fraudulent references or assessments.
- Citation manipulation: Systematically and unjustifiably including references for the purpose of artificially increasing citation counts.
- Misleading use of artificial intelligence tools: Presenting artificially generated information, references, data, or results as authentic and verified, or using such tools in ways that compromise confidentiality, authorship, or scientific integrity.
Textual similarity, methodological errors, or discrepancies in results do not, by themselves, establish scientific misconduct. Each case must be assessed in context, considering the available evidence, the seriousness of the conduct, and intent where it can be established.
Authors' Responsibilities
Authors submitting manuscripts to the journal are responsible for ensuring the integrity and accuracy of their work. They must:
- Ensure that data, results, figures, and materials are authentic and accurately represented.
- Properly cite sources and acknowledge the contributions of other researchers.
- Disclose prior publication, related manuscripts, and simultaneous submissions, where applicable.
- Ensure that authorship reflects actual contributions and that all authors have approved the submitted version.
- Disclose funding sources, conflicts of interest, and relevant ethical approvals.
- Retain supporting records and research data when appropriate and in accordance with applicable requirements.
- Promptly report relevant errors or irregularities identified after submission or publication.
- Disclose the use of artificial intelligence tools when required by the journal's instructions and verify the accuracy of any content produced with such tools.
Responsibilities of the Editorial Team
The editorial team is responsible for addressing credible concerns about scientific integrity in a fair, impartial, and confidential manner. Its responsibilities include:
- Assessing complaints and alerts independently of the identity, affiliation, nationality, or academic position of the individuals involved.
- Reviewing the available information before making editorial decisions.
- Avoiding the treatment of unverified allegations as established facts.
- Requesting explanations, documentation, or supporting evidence when necessary.
- Protecting confidentiality and sharing information only with the parties who need it to assess the case.
- Making reasoned and proportionate decisions based on the evidence available.
- Applying measures consistently and maintaining appropriate records of the process.
Peer review does not replace the authors' responsibility for the integrity of their work, nor does it exempt the journal from examining credible concerns that arise before or after publication.
Detection and Submission of Complaints
Potential scientific misconduct may be identified during the initial editorial screening, peer review, editing, publication, or after an article has been published. Concerns may be raised by readers, reviewers, authors, academic institutions, or other interested parties.
Complaints should identify the manuscript or published article concerned, describe the facts or conduct at issue, and provide any available supporting evidence. The journal may review complaints submitted in good faith even when the information initially provided is incomplete, and will determine whether sufficient grounds exist to initiate an editorial investigation.
Requests for confidentiality will be considered carefully. A complaint will not be automatically dismissed solely because the complainant requests confidentiality; however, the extent to which anonymity can be maintained will depend on the information available and the need to ensure a fair assessment of the case.
Editorial Investigation Procedure
When a potential case of scientific misconduct is identified, the journal may follow the stages below, adapting the procedure to the nature and complexity of the matter:
Stage 1. Preliminary Assessment
The editorial team examines the nature of the complaint, the available evidence, and its potential relevance to scientific or editorial integrity.
Stage 2. Request for Clarification
Where appropriate, the corresponding author and other relevant individuals may be contacted to provide explanations, records, supporting documents, or a response to the concerns raised.
Stage 3. Assessment of the Evidence
The editorial team objectively evaluates the evidence, the circumstances of the case, its seriousness, and the explanations provided. Independent experts or relevant institutions may be consulted when necessary.
Stage 4. Editorial Decision
Based on the findings, the journal may close the matter without further action, request corrections or additional information, reject the manuscript, suspend the editorial process, or adopt other appropriate measures.
Stage 5. Follow-up and Documentation
The journal maintains confidential records of the investigation, relevant communications, evidence reviewed, and decisions taken, and carries out any necessary follow-up.
The journal will seek to address cases within a reasonable period. No rigid deadline will be imposed where doing so would prevent a careful and fair assessment of a complex matter.
Editorial Measures
Depending on the findings, the seriousness of the conduct, and its impact on the integrity of the research, the journal may adopt one or more of the following measures:
- Request explanations, supporting documents, additional information, or corrections.
- Temporarily suspend the editorial process while the concerns are assessed.
- Reject a manuscript when its integrity is compromised or it fails to comply with the journal's ethical requirements.
- Withdraw a manuscript before publication in accordance with the journal's manuscript withdrawal policy.
- For published articles, issue a correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction when justified by the evidence and the applicable editorial policy.
- Contact the relevant institution, funder, or competent body when justified and appropriate.
- Apply proportionate editorial restrictions in serious or repeated cases, provided that the reasons and relevant procedural safeguards are documented.
These measures are not automatic. Each case will be assessed individually, and the reasons supporting any decision will be documented appropriately.
Honest Errors and Corrections
The journal distinguishes scientific misconduct from unintentional errors. Honest mistakes do not automatically constitute ethical violations; however, they must be addressed when they affect the accuracy, interpretation, or reliability of the research.
Authors are expected to report relevant errors promptly once they become aware of them. For published articles, the journal will assess whether a correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction is appropriate, taking into account the nature of the error and its effect on the article's findings and conclusions.
Confidentiality and the Right to Respond
Confidentiality will be maintained, as appropriate, to protect individuals who raise concerns in good faith, those accused of misconduct, and the integrity of the editorial process. Information will be shared only to the extent necessary to assess and address the case.
Where compatible with the circumstances and without compromising the investigation, the individuals involved will have an opportunity to explain their position and provide relevant evidence before a final decision is made.
The journal will avoid publicizing unverified allegations or presenting unsupported conclusions as established facts.
Coordination with Other Editorial Policies
This policy is applied in conjunction with the journal's other editorial policies, including those concerning publication and research ethics, plagiarism, peer review, manuscript withdrawal, conflicts of interest, authorship, the use of artificial intelligence tools, and author submission guidelines.
When concerns involve a published article, the journal will seek to preserve the publication record's traceability and clearly communicate the article's editorial status through the appropriate notice or editorial action.
Good Practice References
In addressing potential scientific misconduct, the journal uses the recommendations and resources of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) as a reference, together with the principles of honesty, transparency, and accountability.
These references will be applied in the context of the research concerned, the applicable ethical requirements, and the journal's editorial policies. Mentioning COPE as a reference does not imply that the journal is a COPE member.
This policy may be reviewed and updated periodically to reflect developments in good scholarly publishing practices and applicable ethical standards.
Institutional Information
Journal: Multidisciplinary Journal Enfoque Transversal
Publisher: Editorial Ciencia Global
Country: Ecuador
Website: https://editorialcienciaglobal.com/index.php/enfoquetransversal/es
Scientific Integrity · Editorial Transparency · Responsible Research
Editorial Ciencia Global | Multidisciplinary Journal Enfoque Transversal
```