Policy on scientific misconduct

Editorial Ciencia Global · Ecuador

Scientific Misconduct Policy

Salud Global Scientific Journal

The Salud Global scientific journal, published by Editorial Ciencia Global, is committed to scientific integrity, editorial transparency, and the responsible dissemination of knowledge. Accordingly, it establishes this policy to prevent, identify, and address potential scientific misconduct during the submission, evaluation, editing, and publication of manuscripts related to medicine, public health, epidemiology, nursing, nutrition, biomedical sciences, and other health-related fields.

This policy is based on the principles of honesty, responsibility, impartiality, confidentiality, and respect for the ethical standards applicable to research and academic publishing. In implementing this policy, the journal refers to the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), taking into account the nature of each case.

Section 01

Conduct Considered Scientific Misconduct

Potential scientific misconduct includes actions or omissions that compromise the authenticity, reliability, originality, or integrity of research or its publication. These include:

  • Plagiarism: appropriating or presenting ideas, texts, data, images, results, or contributions from third parties without properly acknowledging their authorship.
  • Self-plagiarism and redundant publication: substantial reuse of one's own previously published work without appropriate transparency, as well as publication of overlapping results in multiple sources without justification or disclosure.
  • Data fabrication: inventing clinical data, observations, results, participants, or evidence that were not obtained through the stated research.
  • Data falsification: deliberate manipulation, alteration, or omission of data, procedures, images, clinical records, or results in a way that distorts the representation of the research.
  • Improper image manipulation: misleading modification of clinical photographs, diagnostic images, micrographs, figures, charts, or other visual elements that alters their scientific interpretation.
  • Improper authorship: unjustified inclusion or exclusion of authors, attribution of contributions that were not made, or listing a person as an author without their consent.
  • Undeclared conflicts of interest: failure to disclose personal, professional, institutional, or financial interests that may influence the conduct, interpretation, or evaluation of research.
  • Ethical violations in research: lack of required ethical approvals, informed consent, or other safeguards when a study involves human participants, animals, or other materials requiring ethical protection.
  • Breach of confidentiality: unauthorized disclosure of personal data, medical records, identifiable photographs, or other confidential information concerning patients or participants.
  • Manipulation of the editorial process: impersonation of reviewers, falsification of evaluation reports, improper interference with peer review, or submission of fraudulent references and review reports.
  • Citation manipulation: systematic and unjustified inclusion of references intended to artificially inflate the citation counts of an individual, publication, or journal.
  • Misleading use of artificial intelligence tools: presenting artificially generated information, references, data, or results as authentic and verified, as well as using these tools in ways that compromise confidentiality, authorship, or scientific integrity.

Textual similarity, a methodological error, or a discrepancy in results does not, by itself, constitute conclusive evidence of misconduct. Each situation must be examined in light of its context, the available evidence, its severity, and intent where intent can be established.

Section 02

Authors' Responsibilities

Authors are responsible for the accuracy, originality, and rigor of the manuscript submitted to Salud Global. Accordingly, they must:

  1. Ensure that the data, results, figures, and other materials included are authentic and accurately represented.
  2. Properly cite the sources used and acknowledge the contributions of third parties.
  3. Disclose previous publications, related manuscripts, and any potential simultaneous submissions, where applicable.
  4. Ensure that authorship reflects actual contributions and that all authors have approved the submitted version.
  5. Disclose funding sources, conflicts of interest, and relevant ethical approvals.
  6. Comply with informed consent requirements and safeguards for participant protection and the confidentiality of personal and health data.
  7. Where applicable, retain the records and supporting data necessary to address inquiries concerning the research, while respecting privacy regulations and applicable authorizations.
  8. Promptly inform the journal of significant errors or irregularities identified after submission or publication.
  9. Disclose the use of artificial intelligence tools when required by the instructions for authors and verify the accuracy of content produced with their assistance.
  10. Avoid fabricating, falsifying, misleadingly omitting, or manipulating data in ways that may affect the interpretation of scientific results.
Section 03

Responsibilities of the Editorial Team

The editorial team must act impartially, diligently, and confidentially in response to any indication of scientific misconduct. Its responsibilities include:

  • Examining allegations and warning signs independently of the identity, affiliation, nationality, or academic position of the individuals involved.
  • Evaluating the available information before making a decision.
  • Ensuring that unverified allegations are not treated as proven facts.
  • Requesting explanations, documents, or additional evidence when necessary.
  • Protecting the confidentiality of the editorial investigation and limiting the disclosure of information to those who need to participate in the case.
  • Considering the ethical implications of research involving patients, human participants, clinical data, or confidential health information.
  • Making decisions based on evidence and proportionate to the severity of the established facts.
  • Applying consistent editorial measures and documenting the actions taken.

Peer review does not replace authors' responsibility for the integrity of their research, nor does it exempt the journal from examining potential irregularities when reasonable indications exist.

Section 04

Detection and Submission of Allegations

Potential misconduct may be identified during the initial screening, peer review, editing, publication, or after publication. It may also be reported by readers, reviewers, authors, academic institutions, healthcare professionals, or other individuals who provide relevant information.

As far as possible, allegations should identify the manuscript or article, provide a specific description of the events, and include any available documents or evidence. The journal will examine reports submitted in good faith, even when the initial information is incomplete, and determine whether sufficient grounds exist to initiate an editorial review.

When an allegation involves clinical information, medical records, patient images, or personal data, the submitted information must be handled with particular care to avoid unnecessary disclosure or breaches of confidentiality.

The journal will not automatically reject an allegation solely because its author requests confidentiality. However, the possibility of maintaining anonymity will depend on the information provided and the conditions necessary to conduct a fair assessment.

Section 05

Editorial Investigation Procedure

When reasonable grounds exist to suspect potential misconduct, the journal may follow this procedure:

Stage One. Preliminary Assessment

The editorial team will examine the nature of the allegation, the available evidence, and its relevance to scientific or editorial integrity. Where appropriate, it may review data, references, images, or documents related to the research.

Stage Two. Request for Clarification

Where appropriate, the corresponding author or the individuals involved will be contacted to request explanations, supporting documentation, or a response to the reported concerns.

Stage Three. Evidence Assessment

The information received will be evaluated objectively, taking into account the context, the severity of the potential irregularity, and the explanations provided. When necessary, independent experts may be consulted or information may be requested from the relevant institutions.

Stage Four. Editorial Decision

Based on the available information, the journal will determine whether to close the case without further action, request corrections, reject or suspend the editorial process, or take other appropriate measures.

Stage Five. Follow-up and Documentation

Actions and decisions will be documented confidentially. If required by the case, communication with the relevant parties will be maintained, and the need for subsequent measures to protect the integrity of the scientific record will be assessed.

The journal will endeavor to make decisions within a reasonable timeframe. Rigid deadlines will not be imposed if they would prevent complex cases from being properly examined.

Section 06

Editorial Measures

The measures adopted will depend on the nature of the conduct, the strength of the evidence, the stage of the editorial process, and the consequences for the reliability of the work. As appropriate, measures may include:

  • Requests for clarification, supplementary documentation, or corrections.
  • Temporary suspension of the evaluation while the facts are clarified.
  • Rejection of the manuscript when irregularities compromise its integrity or when it fails to comply with editorial standards.
  • Withdrawal of the manuscript before publication, in accordance with the journal's manuscript withdrawal policy.
  • Publication of a correction, expression of concern, or retraction when the article has already been published and sufficient grounds exist.
  • Communication with the affiliated institution, funding body, or other competent entity when justified by the nature of the case and when such communication is appropriate.
  • Application of proportionate editorial restrictions in serious or repeated cases, provided there are sufficient grounds and procedural safeguards are respected.

These measures will not be applied automatically or identically in every case. The journal will assess each situation individually and document the reasons for its decision, seeking to preserve scientific integrity and readers' trust.

Section 07

Honest Errors and Corrections

The journal distinguishes scientific misconduct from unintentional errors that may occur during research. Honest errors will not automatically be considered ethical violations; however, they must be corrected when they affect the accuracy, interpretation, or reliability of the work.

In the health sciences, errors in data, statistical analysis, descriptions of clinical procedures, or interpretation of results may require a specific assessment to determine their impact on the conclusions and scientific value of the article.

When authors identify a significant error, they must inform the editorial team as soon as possible. If the article has already been published, the journal will assess whether to issue a correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction, depending on the scope of the problem and its effects on the conclusions.

Section 08

Confidentiality and the Right to Respond

Cases will be handled with due discretion to protect those who raise concerns in good faith, the individuals concerned, and the integrity of the editorial process. Information will be shared only when necessary to examine the facts or make a decision.

The individuals involved will have an opportunity to provide relevant explanations and evidence before a final editorial decision is made, provided this is compatible with the nature of the case and does not compromise the investigation. The journal will avoid disclosing unverified allegations or issuing public conclusions without sufficient grounds.

When a case involves patient data, medical records, identifiable images, or other confidential health information, the journal will seek to restrict access and disclosure to what is strictly necessary, in accordance with applicable regulations.

Section 09

Coordination with Other Editorial Policies

This policy applies in conjunction with the journal's policies on publication and research ethics, plagiarism, peer review, manuscript withdrawal, conflicts of interest, authorship, participant protection, and the use of artificial intelligence tools, as well as the instructions for authors of Salud Global.

In cases involving health research, the applicable ethical and legal provisions concerning the protection of human participants, the confidentiality of health data, informed consent, and the relevant authorizations required to conduct and disseminate studies must also be considered.

In cases involving articles that have already been published, the journal will seek to ensure that any measures taken preserve the traceability of the scientific record and clearly communicate the editorial status of the work.

Section 10

Good Practice Guidelines

The Salud Global scientific journal refers to the recommendations and resources of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) when addressing potential misconduct in scientific publishing, together with the principles of honesty, transparency, responsibility, and accountability that underpin academic integrity.

These guidelines will be applied in accordance with the characteristics of each research project, the applicable ethical standards, and the journal's institutional policies. Mentioning these guidelines does not, in itself, imply that the publication is a member of COPE.

This policy will be reviewed periodically to maintain its relevance and consistency with good scientific publishing practices and the ethical needs of health research.

Institutional Information

Publisher: Editorial Ciencia Global

Journal: Salud Global

Country: Ecuador

Editorial Platform: Open Journal Systems (OJS)

Official Website: https://editorialcienciaglobal.com/

 

Scientific Integrity, Transparency, and Academic Responsibility

Editorial Ciencia Global · Salud Global Scientific Journal

© Editorial Ciencia Global. All rights reserved.