Ethics in publishing and researc
Publication and Research Ethics
The scientific journal Global Health, published by Editorial Ciencia Global, promotes scientific integrity, editorial transparency, and ethical responsibility at every stage of research, peer review, and publication of contributions related to the health sciences.
General Principles
Global Health recognizes scientific integrity as an essential principle of research and scholarly communication in the health sciences. Accordingly, the journal promotes practices based on honesty, transparency, accountability, impartiality, respect for human dignity, and the protection of people's rights.
The journal conducts its activities in accordance with international good practices in scientific publishing, taking as references the editorial integrity principles promoted by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), as well as relevant recommendations for biomedical research, public health, and other health-related disciplines.
This policy establishes the ethical responsibilities of authors, editors, and reviewers, as well as the principles that must be observed during the preparation, submission, evaluation, and publication of manuscripts received by the journal.
Authors' Ethical Responsibilities
Authors are responsible for ensuring that their contributions are original, scientifically sound, and prepared in accordance with the principles of academic integrity and research ethics in healthcare. In particular, they must:
- Present truthful information and results that accurately reflect the research procedures, methods, and findings.
- Ensure that data, analyses, interpretations, and conclusions are supported by verifiable scientific evidence.
- Properly acknowledge the ideas, methods, results, and contributions of other researchers through appropriate citations and references.
- Identify all individuals who have made substantial contributions to the work and meet the applicable authorship criteria.
- Obtain the necessary permissions to use copyrighted materials, instruments, clinical images, photographs, tables, or other third-party resources, where applicable.
- Declare financial, professional, institutional, or personal conflicts of interest that could influence the research, the interpretation of results, or the conclusions presented.
- Disclose funding sources and institutional support received for conducting the study.
- Comply with the ethical and legal requirements applicable to research involving human participants, personal data, biological samples, animals, or other regulated subjects or materials.
- Protect the privacy, confidentiality, dignity, and rights of participants in health-related studies.
- Cooperate with reasonable requests for clarification, documentation, or verification concerning the manuscript.
Submitting a manuscript implies that its authors accept responsibility for the integrity of the work and the accuracy of the information provided to the journal. Conclusions must be communicated in a balanced manner, avoiding claims that go beyond the available evidence or could lead to misleading interpretations concerning health.
Responsibilities of the Editorial Team
The Global Health editorial team must act independently, impartially, confidentially, and responsibly when managing manuscripts related to medicine, public health, nursing, biomedical sciences, and other areas covered by the journal's scope.
Editorial decisions must be based on the relevance of the work to the journal's scope, its academic quality, its contribution to scientific knowledge, the soundness of its methods, and compliance with applicable editorial and ethical requirements.
Editors must:
- Evaluate manuscripts according to consistent academic standards, without discrimination based on nationality, gender, origin, institutional affiliation, beliefs, or other conditions unrelated to scientific merit.
- Protect the confidentiality of manuscripts, personal data, and non-public information received during the editorial process.
- Identify and manage conflicts of interest that could compromise their impartiality.
- Avoid using unpublished information obtained during editorial handling for personal or third-party benefit.
- Take reasonable measures to identify and examine potential breaches of scientific integrity and research ethics.
- Ensure that editorial decisions are based on academic considerations and are not determined by commercial, personal, or institutional interests unrelated to scientific quality.
- Pay particular attention to the ethical aspects of studies involving human participants, clinical data, sensitive information, and biological materials.
- Promote the correction of significant errors identified after publication, where appropriate.
When an editor has a conflict of interest concerning a manuscript, they must refrain from participating in related decisions and ensure that another editorial representative takes responsibility for its handling.
Reviewers' Responsibilities
Reviewers must contribute to the improvement of manuscripts by providing well-founded, objective, respectful, and relevant comments, taking into account methodological quality, scientific relevance, and the ethical implications of health-related research.
In carrying out their duties, reviewers must:
- Evaluate manuscripts exclusively according to academic, methodological, and scientific criteria.
- Maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts and all information accessed during the review process.
- Declare any conflict of interest that could affect their independence or the objectivity of their recommendations.
- Inform the editorial team promptly if they lack the necessary expertise or cannot complete the review within the agreed timeframe.
- Support their comments with scientific arguments and relevant references when necessary.
- Avoid offensive, discriminatory, or academically irrelevant comments.
- Never use unpublished data, ideas, methods, results, or clinical information from manuscripts for personal or third-party benefit.
- Examine, within their area of expertise, the consistency of the methods, the presentation of results, and the adequacy of the ethical considerations declared by the authors.
- Inform the editorial team of potential scientific integrity issues identified during the review process.
Reviewers may not disclose or distribute submitted manuscripts without editorial authorization. They must also protect confidential information and avoid using external tools or services that could compromise the privacy of the material under review.
Integrity and Responsibility in Research
Research submitted to Global Health must be conducted in accordance with the scientific, ethical, and legal principles applicable to its nature and context. The journal promotes responsible research that contributes to scientific knowledge, human well-being, and the improvement of individual and collective health.
Authors must describe the methods used with sufficient clarity to enable an understanding of the study and, where appropriate, facilitate verification of the results. They must also avoid data fabrication, falsification, deceptive manipulation, deliberate omission of relevant findings, and any other practice that compromises research reliability.
When research involves human participants, personal data, medical records, biological samples, animals, or other elements subject to ethical regulation, authors must comply with the applicable requirements and provide the relevant information.
For studies involving human participants, authors must indicate, where applicable, approval by the competent ethics committee, informed consent, and the measures adopted to protect participants' privacy, confidentiality, dignity, safety, and rights. Research involving vulnerable populations must include any additional ethical safeguards that may be appropriate.
When clinical data, medical records, diagnostic images, or other information that could identify individuals are used, authors must obtain the relevant permissions and implement appropriate anonymization or data-protection measures in accordance with applicable regulations.
For research involving animals, authors must report the required approvals and animal-welfare measures in accordance with applicable legislation and standards.
Studies that do not require approval from an ethics committee must justify this circumstance when relevant to the nature of the research and the applicable requirements.
The journal may request additional documentation when necessary to verify compliance with these requirements. Acceptance of a manuscript does not replace the ethical and legal responsibilities of the researchers or the institutions involved.
Authorship and Contributions
Authorship must reflect genuine intellectual and scientific contributions to the work. Listing an individual as an author must be justified by their substantial participation in the research and compliance with the relevant authorship criteria for the discipline.
In research conducted by clinical teams, laboratories, health centers, hospitals, universities, or other institutions, a distinction must be made between contributions that justify authorship and those involving technical, administrative, or support activities.
Practices such as honorary authorship, including individuals who have not contributed sufficiently, or unjustifiably excluding individuals who have made substantial contributions will not be accepted.
Authors must agree on the authorship list and order before submitting the manuscript and identify individual contributions when requested by the journal.
Changes to authorship after submission must be justified, agreed to by all affected individuals, and approved by the editorial team.
Individuals who contributed to the work but do not meet the authorship criteria may be acknowledged in the acknowledgments section, provided that they have authorized their inclusion and that such recognition respects privacy and applicable agreements.
Conflicts of Interest and Funding
Authors, editors, and reviewers must disclose any circumstance that could influence, or could reasonably be perceived as influencing, their decisions, interpretations, or actions related to a research project or manuscript.
Conflicts of interest may be financial, professional, academic, institutional, personal, or of another relevant nature. In the health sciences, they may also involve relationships with pharmaceutical companies, medical-device manufacturers, healthcare service providers, or other entities whose interests could be affected by research findings.
Authors must identify the sources of research funding and, where applicable, disclose the role of funding organizations in the study design, participant selection, data collection and analysis, interpretation of results, and manuscript preparation.
The existence of a conflict of interest does not automatically result in rejection of a contribution. Its management will depend on the nature of the conflict, its potential influence, and the measures necessary to ensure editorial transparency, independence, and impartiality.
Redundant Publication and Other Practices Contrary to Integrity
Manuscripts submitted to Global Health must comply with the principles of originality and academic attribution. Authors must disclose previous publications, earlier versions, study registrations, or related works that may be relevant to assessing the originality of their contribution.
Practices such as duplicate publication, artificially fragmenting results to multiply publications without scientific justification, submitting the same manuscript simultaneously to multiple journals when prohibited by their editorial policies, and misappropriating others' ideas or results will not be accepted.
When a manuscript reuses data, methods, images, tables, instruments, or excerpts from previous works by the same authors, the sources must be properly identified and cited, and the relationship between publications must be explained when necessary.
In clinical and epidemiological research, the reuse of datasets must comply with the relevant permissions, informed-consent conditions where applicable, and personal-data protection requirements.
Legitimate reuse of materials or data does not in itself constitute misconduct, provided that it is carried out transparently, with proper attribution, and in compliance with applicable terms of use.
Specific procedures for identifying and addressing textual similarities are described in the journal's Anti-Plagiarism Policy.
Responsible Use of Artificial Intelligence Tools
Authors must use generative artificial intelligence tools and other automated systems responsibly, transparently, and in a manner consistent with scientific integrity, particularly when these tools are used to prepare health-related content or analyze clinical and biomedical information.
When the use of these tools is relevant to manuscript preparation, data analysis, content generation, image creation or modification, interpretation of results, or research development, it must be disclosed in accordance with the journal's editorial instructions and the characteristics of the work.
Authors retain full responsibility for the submitted content, including the accuracy of claims, the validity of references, the originality of materials, the reproducibility of procedures, and compliance with third-party rights.
Artificial intelligence tools may not be listed as authors because they cannot assume academic responsibility or fulfill the obligations associated with scientific authorship.
Unpublished manuscripts, medical records, identifiable patient data, confidential information, or other personal or sensitive data must not be entered into external artificial intelligence tools when doing so could compromise confidentiality, data protection, or participants' rights.
Reviewers and editors must also refrain from using external artificial intelligence tools to process confidential manuscripts without authorization and adequate information-protection safeguards.
The use of artificial intelligence does not exempt researchers from verifying scientific information, bibliographic references, and conclusions, or from complying with the ethical and legal principles applicable to health research.
Corrections, Retractions, and Post-Publication Responsibility
The ethical responsibilities of those involved do not end when an article is published. Authors must promptly notify the journal of any substantial errors identified in their published work and cooperate in implementing appropriate corrective measures.
When errors affecting the accuracy or interpretation of results are identified, the journal will assess whether a correction, clarification, or other appropriate editorial communication is necessary.
When there is evidence of serious problems that compromise an article's reliability, originality, or integrity, measures such as an expression of concern or retraction may be considered, depending on the nature of the case and the available evidence.
In health-related publications, these measures are particularly important when errors or irregularities could affect the interpretation of scientific evidence, clinical practice, subsequent research, or public health decisions.
Decisions will be made with a view to preserving the transparency of the scientific record, respecting the parties involved, and properly documenting the measures taken.
Procedures for investigating and resolving potential cases of data fabrication or falsification, result manipulation, improper authorship, and other conduct contrary to scientific integrity are described in the journal's Scientific Misconduct Policy.
Handling Potential Breaches
When reports are received or reasonable indications of non-compliance with this policy are identified, the journal may conduct a preliminary assessment and request explanations or documentation from the individuals involved.
These cases will be handled confidentially, impartially, and proportionately to the nature of the allegations, ensuring that the parties have an opportunity to respond and avoiding premature conclusions.
When necessary, the journal may request additional information, consult independent specialists, or contact the relevant institutions, provided that there is adequate justification and applicable legal obligations are respected.
In cases involving health research, the journal may examine, where appropriate, issues relating to ethical approval, informed consent, personal-data protection, clinical-data integrity, and the responsible communication of results.
Editorial measures will be determined according to the seriousness of the facts, the available evidence, and the applicable institutional policies. These measures may include suspension of the editorial process, rejection of a manuscript, publication of a correction or retraction, or other justified actions.
The detailed handling of misconduct and the specific measures applicable to such cases will be governed by the journal's Scientific Misconduct Policy and other relevant editorial provisions.
Reference Framework
Global Health uses international good practices and recommendations to strengthen research ethics and scientific publishing, including:
- Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE): Principles and resources for editorial ethics, manuscript review, and the handling of potential breaches.
- World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki: Where applicable to medical research involving human participants.
- International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE): Relevant recommendations concerning manuscript preparation, authorship, conflicts of interest, and editorial conduct in medical publishing.
- World Health Organization (WHO): Relevant principles and recommendations for public health research, research ethics, and the protection of individuals.
- Applicable national and international regulations: Provisions concerning personal-data protection, participants' rights, animal welfare, and scientific research.
Reference to these documents does not imply institutional affiliation or automatic adoption of all their requirements. Their application will depend on the nature of the manuscript, the journal's formally approved policies, and the relevant legal provisions.
Final Provision
Global Health considers ethics and scientific integrity to be shared responsibilities of everyone involved in research and scholarly communication in the health sciences.
Submitting a manuscript implies that the authors are familiar with and accept the applicable editorial provisions. They undertake to provide truthful information, respect third-party rights, protect participants' information, and cooperate with reasonable actions taken by the journal to safeguard the integrity of the scientific record.
The journal may review and update this policy to maintain consistency with evolving international good practices, scientific advances, the needs of the research community, and applicable regulations.
Institutional Information
Publisher: Editorial Ciencia Global.
Journal: Global Health.
Official Website: editorialcienciaglobal.com
Integrity, Transparency, and Scientific Responsibility
Global Health promotes a culture of academic honesty, impartial review, respect for human rights, and shared responsibility to strengthen trust in research and contribute to the advancement of scientific knowledge in health.
```