Scientific Misconduct Policy

Horizonte Educativo Journal

Scientific Misconduct Policy

Horizonte Educativo Journal, published by Editorial Ciencia Global, is committed to promoting scientific integrity, transparency, academic responsibility, and good practices in research and the publication of scientific results. The journal considers that trust in academic literature depends on the honesty of authors, the impartiality of reviewers, and the responsibility of the editorial team throughout every stage of the publication process.

This policy establishes the principles and procedures for preventing, identifying, and managing potential scientific misconduct involving submitted manuscripts and published articles. Its implementation is guided by the recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and by international principles of ethics and integrity in scholarly communication.

1. General Principles of Scientific Integrity

All participants in the editorial process must act in accordance with the principles of honesty, methodological rigor, transparency, respect for intellectual property, confidentiality, impartiality, and accountability.

Authors are responsible for the truthfulness of the information presented, the integrity of the data, the proper acknowledgment of sources, and compliance with the ethical requirements applicable to their research. Reviewers must provide objective, confidential, and well-founded assessments, while the editorial team must ensure that decisions are made independently and on the basis of academic and scientific criteria.

The journal will not tolerate conduct involving deception, deliberate manipulation, misappropriation of intellectual contributions, or violations of the ethical principles governing scientific research and publication.

2. Conduct Considered Scientific Misconduct

Potential forms of scientific misconduct include, but are not limited to, the following:

2.1. Data Fabrication

This consists of inventing data, observations, results, participants, experiments, or evidence and presenting them as though they had been obtained through actual research.

2.2. Data Falsification or Manipulation

This includes the alteration, selective omission, or improper manipulation of data, procedures, images, results, or research materials in order to present misleading conclusions or distort findings.

2.3. Plagiarism and Intellectual Appropriation

This includes reproducing or using third parties’ texts, ideas, results, data, images, or contributions without properly acknowledging their origin, in accordance with the journal’s anti-plagiarism policy.

2.4. Duplicate or Redundant Publication

This consists of submitting or publishing the same work, or substantially overlapping results, in more than one publication without appropriate transparency, academic justification, or editorial authorization where required.

2.5. Authorship Manipulation

This includes listing authors who made no substantial contributions, unjustifiably excluding individuals who contributed to the work, falsely attributing authorship, or providing misleading information about individual contributions.

2.6. Undisclosed Conflicts of Interest

This refers to failing to disclose financial, professional, institutional, or personal relationships that could improperly influence the design, conduct, interpretation, review, or publication of research.

2.7. Manipulation of the Peer Review Process

This includes impersonating reviewers, providing false identities or credentials, improperly interfering with review reports, and any attempt to fraudulently influence editorial decisions.

2.8. Non-compliance with Research Ethics Standards

This includes conducting research involving human participants, animals, or other study subjects without the authorizations, approvals, or ethical safeguards required by the nature of the study and applicable regulations.

2.9. Irresponsible Use of Artificial Intelligence Tools

This includes using artificial intelligence tools to fabricate data, invent references, produce misleading content, conceal relevant information, or present unverified results as scientific evidence. Authors retain full responsibility for the accuracy, integrity, and originality of their manuscripts.

2.10. Other Conduct Contrary to Scientific Integrity

The journal may also investigate other actions that compromise research reliability, editorial transparency, or the integrity of the scientific record, provided that reasonable grounds justify such a review.

3. Authors’ Responsibilities

Authors must ensure that their manuscripts are prepared and submitted in accordance with the principles of scientific integrity and the journal’s editorial guidelines. In particular, they must:

  • Present truthful, verifiable information consistent with the research procedures actually carried out.
  • Avoid the fabrication, falsification, manipulation, or improper concealment of data and results.
  • Acknowledge sources appropriately and respect intellectual property rights.
  • Declare each author’s contributions and obtain all authors’ approval of the version submitted for publication.
  • Report ethical approvals, informed consent, and required permissions, where applicable.
  • Disclose relevant conflicts of interest and research funding sources.
  • Report any substantial error identified after submission or publication of the article.
  • Cooperate in good faith with requests for clarification or investigations conducted by the editorial team.

Submitting a manuscript implies that the authors accept these responsibilities.

4. Responsibilities of Reviewers and the Editorial Team

Reviewers must assess manuscripts impartially, confidentially, and with academic rigor. They may not use unpublished information for personal benefit or disclose reviewed content without authorization. They must also inform the editor of potential conflicts of interest and report any relevant indications of scientific irregularities.

The editorial team is responsible for examining allegations or indications of potential misconduct, protecting the confidentiality of information, requesting necessary clarifications, and making well-founded decisions.

The journal will seek to avoid premature judgments and will not consider a violation proven solely because an allegation has been made, textual similarities have been identified, or an unverified suspicion exists.

5. Detection and Receipt of Allegations

Potential misconduct may be identified during the initial editorial screening, peer review, manuscript editing, or after publication. It may also be reported through documented allegations submitted by readers, researchers, reviewers, institutions, or other individuals with relevant information.

Whenever possible, allegations should identify the manuscript or article, describe the events specifically, and provide the available evidence. The journal will assess the information received regardless of the identity, affiliation, or academic position of the person submitting it.

The editorial team may use similarity-detection tools, reference checks, data analysis, and other verification methods appropriate to the nature of the case. The results of these tools will be interpreted critically and in context and will not replace editorial assessment.

6. Editorial Investigation Procedure

When reasonable indications of potential scientific misconduct exist, the journal may initiate an internal review in accordance with the following stages:

  1. Preliminary assessment: examination of the allegation, editorial history, and available information to determine whether there are grounds for an investigation.
  2. Evidence gathering: review of documents, data, original sources, similarity reports, editorial records, or other relevant materials.
  3. Communication with authors: request for explanations, clarifications, or supplementary documentation, as appropriate.
  4. Consultation with specialists or institutions: where the nature or complexity of the case requires it, the journal may seek independent advice or contact the relevant institutions.
  5. Assessment of the facts: analysis of the evidence and responses received, while respecting impartiality and confidentiality.
  6. Editorial decision: determination of appropriate measures in light of the seriousness of the conduct, the verified information, and good practices in scholarly publishing.
  7. Documentation and follow-up: recording the actions taken and communicating the decision to the relevant parties to the extent necessary and compatible with the confidentiality of the procedure.

During the investigation, the journal may temporarily suspend the review or publication of a manuscript when necessary to protect the integrity of the editorial process.

7. Editorial Measures in Response to Misconduct

Measures will be determined proportionately to the nature, seriousness, and consequences of the identified conduct. Depending on the circumstances, they may include:

  • A request for clarification or additional documentation.
  • A request for corrections in cases involving remediable errors that do not substantially compromise the integrity of the work.
  • Returning the manuscript for appropriate revisions.
  • Rejecting the manuscript when a violation incompatible with the journal’s standards is established.
  • Temporarily suspending the editorial process while relevant concerns are investigated.
  • Publishing a correction or an expression of concern regarding a published article.
  • Retracting an article when sufficient grounds are established to seriously question its integrity or reliability.
  • Contacting the authors’ affiliated institutions or other competent bodies when the seriousness of the case warrants it.

Measures will not be applied automatically or based solely on similarity percentages, suspicions, or isolated results from technological tools. Every decision must be supported by a reasoned assessment of the available evidence.

8. Handling Post-publication Cases

If potential misconduct is identified after publication, Horizonte Educativo Journal will examine the relevant background and determine whether the article should remain unchanged, be corrected, be subject to an expression of concern, or be retracted.

When a measure affects the interpretation or reliability of an article, the journal will seek to inform readers clearly about the nature and reasons for the action. Whenever possible, the bibliographic record and relevant editorial documentation will be retained to preserve the traceability of the publication.

Retraction will not be used as an automatic punitive measure, but as a means of alerting readers that a work is unreliable or that serious irregularities compromise the scientific record.

9. Confidentiality, Impartiality, and Protection of the Parties

The journal will handle allegations and investigations confidentially, restricting access to information to those who need to participate in the procedure.

All parties involved will have an opportunity to provide information and explanations, where appropriate. Decisions will be made without discrimination based on nationality, gender, institutional affiliation, geographical origin, academic career, or other factors unrelated to an objective assessment of the facts.

The journal will seek to prevent the dissemination of unverified allegations and will take particular care not to present a suspicion as an established violation.

10. Commitment to Good Scientific Practices

Horizonte Educativo Journal considers the prevention and management of scientific misconduct to be a shared responsibility among authors, reviewers, editors, and research institutions.

Accordingly, it promotes methodological transparency, responsible data preservation, proper attribution of intellectual contributions, disclosure of conflicts of interest, and respect for the ethical principles applicable to each research project.

The journal will use the recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and other recognized good practices in scholarly publishing as references for its decisions and to strengthen the integrity of its editorial processes.

Final provision: every situation involving potential scientific misconduct will be assessed individually and on the basis of verifiable evidence. Editorial decisions must be justified, proportionate to the identified facts, and aimed at preserving trust in research and the scientific record.