Publication and Research Ethics
Publication and Research Ethics
Principles, responsibilities, and procedures to ensure integrity, transparency, and accountability in scientific communication concerning administration, business management, and global business.
Commitment to Research Ethics
The Global Administration Journal, published by Editorial Ciencia Global (Ecuador), considers publication ethics and scientific research ethics fundamental principles for ensuring the quality, credibility, and transparency of academic knowledge in the fields of administration, business management, finance, leadership, and global business.
The journal promotes honesty, accountability, impartiality, editorial independence, respect for copyright, and the protection of individuals participating in research. Its editorial processes are guided by international best practices in publication ethics, including the recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), without implying formal affiliation with that organization.
All authors, editors, reviewers, and contributors involved in the editorial process must act with integrity and comply with the provisions established in this policy. The journal may take editorial action when it identifies violations that compromise the originality, validity, or integrity of submitted or published works.
Responsibilities of Authors
Authors submitting manuscripts to the Global Administration Journal must fulfill the following responsibilities:
01. Originality and Exclusivity
Submit original works related to administration, business management, organizational behavior, finance, marketing, entrepreneurship, innovation, and other related fields. Manuscripts must not have been previously published or be under evaluation by another journal at the same time. Preliminary versions deposited in repositories or preprint platforms must be disclosed so that they can be assessed in accordance with the journal's editorial policies.
02. Integrity of Results
Ensure that the data, methods, results, tables, figures, documents, and other materials submitted are authentic, accurate, and verifiable. Fabrication, falsification, misleading manipulation, or deliberate omission of information that could alter the interpretation of research findings concerning organizations, companies, markets, financial management, human resources, or public administration is prohibited.
03. Responsible Authorship
Include as authors only those who have made substantial intellectual or scientific contributions to the work, participated in reviewing and approving the final version, and accepted the corresponding responsibility. Individuals who have contributed but do not meet the authorship criteria may be acknowledged, with their consent.
04. Manuscript Approval
Ensure that all authors have reviewed and approved the submitted version, agree to its submission to the journal, and understand the responsibilities associated with publication. They must also verify that the conclusions, recommendations, and management proposals are supported by the evidence presented.
05. Disclosure of Funding and Conflicts of Interest
Disclose funding sources, institutional support, and any personal, professional, financial, or institutional relationship that could influence the research or the interpretation of its results. In studies involving companies, organizations, or markets, relevant relationships with the entities being analyzed must be declared. If no conflicts of interest exist, this must be explicitly stated.
06. Compliance with Ethical Requirements
Declare ethics committee approvals, informed consent procedures, and relevant authorizations whenever required by the nature of the research, particularly in studies involving workers, customers, executives, employees, consumers, or other human participants.
07. Respect for Intellectual Property
Properly cite the sources used and obtain the necessary permissions to reproduce copyright-protected materials. Plagiarism, misappropriation of ideas, misleading redundant publication, and manipulation of bibliographic references, business reports, institutional documents, and information sources are prohibited.
08. Data Availability and Traceability
Provide, where appropriate and legally and ethically possible, sufficient information to understand and verify the research procedures and results. Studies using financial, commercial, employment-related, institutional, or strategic data must respect justified confidentiality restrictions, applicable agreements, and personal data protection requirements.
09. Post-Publication Corrections
Promptly notify the journal when significant errors are identified in published works and cooperate with any necessary correction, clarification, or retraction procedures, particularly when the errors affect the data, analyses, results, or recommendations derived from the research.
Failure to fulfill these responsibilities may result in manuscript rejection, a request for clarification, or other editorial measures proportionate to the nature and severity of the case.
Responsibilities of Editors and Reviewers
The editorial leadership, members of the editorial board, and external reviewers must act with independence, impartiality, confidentiality, and scientific responsibility. Their evaluations must consider the relevance of the research to the field of administration and its contribution to theoretical and practical knowledge.
Their responsibilities include:
01. Editorial Impartiality
Evaluate manuscripts based on scientific quality, originality, thematic relevance, methodological rigor, and contribution to knowledge, without discrimination based on the authors' nationality, gender, institutional affiliation, beliefs, or other personal characteristics. Decisions must not depend on commercial interests or the organization being studied.
02. Confidentiality
Protect manuscripts, associated data, evaluation reports, and editorial communications. Unpublished information must not be disclosed or used for purposes unrelated to the evaluation process, including internal or strategic data belonging to companies and organizations examined in the research.
03. Management of Conflicts of Interest
Disclose any relationship that could compromise the objectivity of an evaluation or editorial decision and refrain from participating when a conflict affects independence, such as employment, financial, professional, or institutional ties with the authors or the entities being studied.
04. Selection of Reviewers
Ensure, as far as possible, that manuscripts are evaluated by specialists with relevant expertise, independence from the authors, and no significant conflicts of interest. Where appropriate, their knowledge of areas such as strategic administration, finance, human resources, marketing, innovation, and public management will be considered.
05. Evidence-Based Decisions
Make editorial decisions based on review reports, manuscript quality, the journal's policies, and applicable scientific criteria. The final decision rests with the competent editorial authority and must prioritize academic merit, transparency, and the relevance of the research.
06. Protection of Scientific Integrity
Examine suspicions of plagiarism, data manipulation, improper authorship, duplicate publication, or other violations by following documented procedures and respecting the parties' right to provide explanations.
07. Responsible Use of Unpublished Materials
Refrain from using information, results, methods, business strategies, or ideas obtained through manuscript review for personal or professional benefit, while respecting the confidentiality of submitted works.
08. Transparency and Accountability
Maintain appropriate records of editorial decisions and handle allegations, corrections, and retractions in a proportionate, confidential, and impartial manner.
Participation in editorial processes must not be used to advance personal, institutional, or commercial interests or to improperly influence publication decisions.
Research Involving Human Participants
The Global Administration Journal requires research involving people, identifiable personal information, or sensitive data to respect the principles of dignity, autonomy, privacy, confidentiality, beneficence, and protection against potential harm. This includes, among other areas, studies involving workers, executives, consumers, customers, entrepreneurs, and members of public or private organizations.
Authors must describe the ethical procedures applied in the manuscript and report, as appropriate:
When a study is legally and ethically exempt from review by an ethics committee, the authors must explain the grounds for the exemption and identify, where applicable, the body that determined it.
The journal may request supplementary documentation when necessary to verify compliance with ethical requirements. Missing essential information, lack of consent where required, or reasonable concerns regarding participant protection may result in a request for clarification or manuscript rejection.
Studies using secondary data, surveys, interviews, business records, or institutional documents must comply with the rules applicable to their use and protect the confidential information of the individuals and organizations involved.
Responsibility for obtaining the relevant authorizations and approvals rests with the authors and the institutions responsible for the research. The journal does not replace the functions of ethics committees or competent authorities.
Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence
The Global Administration Journal recognizes that generative artificial intelligence (AI) tools may be used to support certain research and scientific communication activities. However, their use must be transparent, responsible, and consistent with the principles of academic integrity, confidentiality, and verifiability, particularly when analyzing financial, business, employment-related, or organizational data.
Authorship and Responsibility
Artificial intelligence tools cannot be listed as authors or assume responsibility for a manuscript. Authorship is reserved exclusively for individuals who meet the criteria established by the journal.
Authors are responsible for all submitted content, including text, data, analyses, images, code, references, and conclusions produced with the assistance of AI tools. They must verify the accuracy of the results, check bibliographic references, and correct any false, fabricated, or unverifiable information.
Disclosure of Artificial Intelligence Use
Authors must disclose the substantive use of generative AI tools when these have contributed to the preparation of scientific content, analysis or interpretation of information, generation of images or code, or other activities relevant to the research.
The disclosure must identify the tool used and describe its purpose and scope. Where appropriate, it must also explain how the generated results were verified.
Limited assistance with spelling, grammar, or minor language adjustments will not necessarily require a specific disclosure, unless the nature of the use or the applicable editorial instructions indicate otherwise.
AI Use by Reviewers and Editors
Reviewers and editors must protect the confidentiality of manuscripts and the information they access during the editorial process. They must not enter unpublished manuscripts, confidential reports, personal data, or restricted business information into external AI tools when doing so could compromise confidentiality or violate data protection obligations.
AI does not replace reviewers' scientific judgment or editors' responsibility for decision-making. Any use of these tools must comply with the journal's policies and the applicable security and confidentiality safeguards.
Integrity and Misuse
Using AI tools to fabricate data, invent references, manipulate results, conceal the origin of third-party materials, produce misleading content, or violate the rights of others is unacceptable.
When there are indications of misuse, the journal may request explanations and additional documentation from the authors. Editorial decisions will take into account the nature of the violation, its consequences for scientific integrity, and the responses provided by the individuals involved.
Handling Suspected Ethical Misconduct
When the Global Administration Journal receives a complaint or identifies indications of a possible ethical violation, it will conduct an initial assessment to determine the relevance of the information submitted and the measures required.
The procedure may include reviewing evidence, requesting explanations from the authors, consulting reviewers or independent specialists, and, where appropriate, communicating with the authors' affiliated institutions or the competent authorities.
Actions will be carried out impartially, documented, and confidentially, while respecting the right of the individuals involved to respond. The journal may take proportionate editorial measures, such as requesting corrections, rejecting a manuscript, publishing an expression of concern, or issuing a retraction when the work has already been published and sufficient grounds exist.
Complaints must be assessed on the basis of verifiable information. The journal will avoid presenting unconfirmed suspicions as facts and will seek to protect both the integrity of the scientific record and the rights of the individuals involved.
Commitment to Scientific Integrity
The Global Administration Journal considers publication ethics a shared responsibility among authors, reviewers, editors, and academic and professional institutions.
Through the implementation of these provisions, the journal seeks to strengthen trust in scientific communication, preserve the quality of published articles, and contribute to an academic community committed to honesty, methodological rigor, transparency, and respect for the ethical principles of research in administration and organizational management.
Research Ethics · Academic Integrity · Editorial Transparency